Ever since you saw Beyoncé’s engagement ring on Access Hollywood, you’ve been thinking about proposing with an emerald cut diamond. You love its defined silhouette and mesmerizing sparkle, but you’re also hesitant. Beyoncé’s 18-carat sparkler aside, aren’t these diamonds too plain? Too vintage? Too small?
Emerald cut diamonds have sparked plenty of misconceptions—but it’s time to set the record straight. Favored by royalty and Hollywood icons, this shape has long been a symbol of luxury and refinement. Its bold, step-cut facets create a luxurious hall-of-mirrors effect while the elongated shape makes the finger look sleek and refined. And when it comes to size, emerald cuts actually appear larger per carat than many other shapes, making them an excellent choice for maximizing your budget.
Despite these clear advantages, there are still a lot of misconceptions about emerald cut diamonds. Let’s debunk the five biggest ones and reveal why this timeless shape deserves a place on your finger.
The Kamellie with a 2 carat Emerald cut Diamond and The Alice with a 2 carat Emerald cut Diamond in Yellow Gold
What Is an Emerald Cut Diamond?
Dating back to the Art Deco era, the emerald cut diamond is one of the oldest and most refined shapes. Don’t be confused by the name: unlike green emerald gemstones, “emerald cut” refers to the shape, not the color. With its clean lines and understated shimmer, this cut has long been a favorite of those who appreciate Old World luxury.
Unlike round brilliant diamonds, whose tiny, intricate facets create a fiery sparkle, emerald cuts feature long, parallel facets that reflect light in bold, dramatic flashes rather than a traditional shimmer. A higher length-to-width ratio (1.4:1 or more) enhances this effect even further. And because emerald cuts distribute their weight across a larger surface, they often appear bigger per carat than round or cushion diamonds, making them a stunning choice for those who want maximum presence without increasing carat size.
Myth 1: Emerald Cut Diamonds Don’t Sparkle Enough
"I want a diamond that dazzles—emerald cuts just don’t have enough sparkle!"
This is one of the biggest misconceptions about emerald cut diamonds. Because they don’t have the same faceting style as round or cushion cuts, people assume they’ll look dull or flat. In reality, emerald cuts sparkle—but in their own bold, refined way.
The Pave Twig with a 4 carat Emerald cut Diamond in Yellow Gold
Unlike brilliant cuts, which scatter light in all directions, emerald cuts create long, dramatic flashes—like mirrors catching the sun. Their signature hall-of-mirrors effect gives them a beautiful, understated shimmer that feels both elegant and eye-catching.
If you want even more brilliance, pair an emerald cut with a pavé band to increase its radiance. The Pavé Twig with an emerald cut diamond blends classic beauty with nature-inspired details. Its pavé setting catches the light with every movement, while the 1.5mm band mimics the delicate curves and textures of a twig, creating a ring that feels both organic and luxurious.
The Pave Twig with a 4 carat Emerald cut Diamond in Yellow Gold
Myth 2: Emerald Cut Diamonds Show Too Many Flaws
"You have to buy a flawless emerald cut, or it’ll look terrible."
This is one of the most common myths about emerald cut diamonds. Because they have large, open facets, many assume that even the tiniest inclusion will stand out—making anything less than a Flawless (FL) or Internally Flawless (IF) diamond a risky choice.
Yes, emerald cuts highlight clarity, but that doesn’t mean you need perfection. A VS1 or VS2 clarity emerald cut is usually completely eye-clean, meaning any inclusions are invisible to the naked eye. The key is placement—avoiding inclusions in the center ensures they won’t be noticeable.
For a breathtaking emerald cut ring with extra brilliance, The Patricia is an inspired choice. This side-stone engagement ring pairs an emerald cut center stone with an alternating band of baguette and round diamonds, adding dimension and sparkle. A hidden halo beneath the center stone adds a touch of secret radiance, proving that an emerald cut can shine beautifully—even without a flawless grade.
The Patricia with a 3 carat Emerald cut Diamond and The Hailey band in Yellow Gold
Myth 3: Emerald Cuts Look Too Small for Their Carat Weight
"Emerald cuts are tiny for their carat weight!"
Some people worry that emerald cut diamonds look smaller than other shapes and won’t provide enough "finger coverage" for the price. In reality, emerald cuts actually appear larger than many other diamonds of the same carat weight.
Thanks to their large table (the top surface of the diamond), emerald cuts have more visible surface area than round diamonds of the same weight. Their long, rectangular shape also creates an elongating effect, making fingers look more slender and refined. If maximizing size is a priority, an emerald cut is one of the best choices for your budget.
If you want to make your emerald cut appear even bigger, The Ashley solitaire engagement ring is a stunning option. Its slender band amplifies the size and brilliance of the center stone while the low-profile silhouette supports maximum comfort and practicality. Simple yet sophisticated, The Ashley setting is proof that an emerald cut can make a bold statement.
The Ashley with a 2.5 carat Emerald cut Diamond in Yellow Gold
Myth 4: Emerald Cut Diamonds Are Too Traditional or Old-Fashioned
"Emerald cuts? Aren’t those kind of… outdated?"
Some assume emerald cut diamonds have fallen out of style and been overshadowed by trendy favorites like oval and cushion cuts. In reality, emerald cuts are timeless, and they’ve never lost their appeal.
The Eliza with a 2 carat Emerald cut Diamond in Yellow Gold
From classic Hollywood icons to today’s biggest celebrities, this shape continues to make a statement. Beyoncé, Amal Clooney, and Jennifer Lopez all wear emerald cut engagement rings, proving that its clean lines and bold structure are as striking now as ever. The geometric silhouette gives it a sleek, modern feel, while its versatility allows it to shine in both vintage and modern settings.
For a fresh, fashion-forward take, choose The Eliza, a half-bezel solitaire engagement ring that seamlessly blends vintage charm with contemporary chic. Its emerald-cut center stone is securely held in a sleek bezel setting, allowing maximum light to shine through—proof that an emerald cut can feel both classic and effortlessly modern.
The Eliza with a 2 carat Emerald cut Diamond and The Samantha band in Yellow Gold
Myth 5: They’re Hard to Find in Lab-Grown Options
"Lab-grown emerald cuts? Good luck finding one!"
Many buyers assume lab-grown emerald cut diamonds are rare or unavailable, but that couldn’t be further from the truth. These diamonds are actually widely available, and they offer incredible value.
Lab-grown diamonds are chemically and physically identical to mined diamonds but come at a more affordable price, allowing you to go bigger without stretching your budget. They’re also a sustainable choice, making them perfect for those who want both beauty and responsibility in their ring.
The Penelope side-stone engagement ring features a delicate, thin band with six pavé-set accents along the shoulders for extra sparkle. Four low-profile micro diamonds in the bridge area add a hidden touch of radiance, making it the perfect setting to showcase a stunning emerald cut diamond.
The Penelope with a 3 carat Emerald cut Diamond and The Patricia band in White Gold
Conclusion
If you've overlooked emerald cuts before, it's time to take a second look. They break the rules, defy trends, and stand out for all the right reasons—making them an unforgettable choice for an engagement ring.
Emerald cut diamonds have been misunderstood for far too long. Instead of being a "wrong choice," they’re one of the most stylish and upscale cuts available. Why settle for ordinary when you can have extraordinary? Shop for an emerald cut engagement ring on the Keyzar website and make it yours!
Engagement Rings
Design your engagement ring and center stone
